Login Contact Us Blog Shop

Wastewater Concerns Raise Questions About Stock Island’s Water Quality

STOCK ISLAND, FL.

The Florida Keys contain some of the most important marine ecosystems in the country, and the region’s marine life depends on healthy water quality. However, wastewater disposal on Stock Island is raising questions about whether current practices are adequately protecting these environments.

Concerns center around Key West Resort Utilities Corp. (KWRU), a privately operated wastewater treatment facility on Stock Island. Advocates from Friends of the Lower Keys (FOLKS) have reported findings that suggest treated wastewater injected underground at the facility may be resurfacing through the seafloor and entering nearby waters within the Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary.

The issue has gained attention in recent months, with local environmental organizations such as Keys Last Stand questioning wastewater management and its potential impacts on nearby marine ecosystems. Their efforts have helped bring the issue before the Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary Advisory Council, which recently approved a resolution turning to state and federal agencies to investigate the concerns and pursue action.

How Does Wastewater End Up Underground?

Wastewater treatment is an essential part of protecting public health and the environment. Wastewater is collected from homes and businesses then undergoes treatment to remove solids, organic matter and other pollutants. Once treated the remaining water must be safely disposed of.

In parts of the Florida Keys, one method involves underground injection wells. These systems pump treated wastewater into underground geological formations, where it is intended to remain contained. 

However, much of the Florida Keys is underlain by porous limestone, with geological formations that can allow groundwater to move through cracks, openings and permeable rock. The concern now is that the wastewater injected into shallow wells on Stock Island may be traveling through these underground pathways and eventually reaching nearby waters.

What Has Been Found?

According to a report by Keys Weekly on October 1, 2026, Friends of the Lower Keys (FOLKS) collected water samples from areas where water appeared to be bubbling up through the seafloor. Some of these locations were within approximately 300 feet of the facility’s injection wells.

The samples were submitted for testing at Florida International University. According to FOLKS, their testing identified elevated concentrations of sucralose which is an artificial sweetener commonly used as an indicator of human wastewater. Because sucralose can pass through conventional wastewater treatment processes relatively unchanged, it helps researchers identify potential wastewater contamination.

The organization also documented underwater footage of the suspected upwellings and reported differences in salinity and temperature between the water emerging from the seafloor and the surrounding seawater.

These findings have caused suspicion that treated wastewater is moving through the limestone and eventually reaching surface waters. However, further scientific investigation is needed to establish a more definitive connection between the injection wells and the suspected contamination.

Why Is This a Concern for Marine Life?

This wastewater making its way into coastal waters is concerning because even treated it can still contain nutrients and other substances that may affect marine ecosystems.

Nitrogen and phosphorus are two nutrients commonly associated with wastewater. While both occur naturally in marine environments, excessive amounts can contribute to algae growth which reduces water clarity and disrupts the balance of coastal ecosystems. Algae also competes with corals for space and resources. That combined with rising ocean temperatures, disease and other stressors, declining water quality can make our already struggling coral even more difficult to protect.

Call for Action

Local environmental organizations Friends of the Lower Keys (FOLKS) and Keys Last Stand have been working to raise awareness about wastewater management and its impacts on water quality throughout the Florida Keys. Their efforts helped bring the Stock Island concerns before The Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary Advisory Council, which unanimously approved a resolution on September 15, 2026, acknowledging evidence presented by Friends of the Lower Keys suggesting that wastewater from KW Resort Utilities Corp.’s shallow injection wells may be emerging in nearby sanctuary waters. The resolution calls on state and federal regulatory agencies to determine what corrective action is warranted.

The issue has also gained support from local government leaders. On November 5, 2026, the Key West City Commission passed Resolution 26-6028, supporting regulatory agencies in addressing the concerns. Monroe County is also bringing the issue forward for consideration at an upcoming Board of County Commissioners meeting.

What Happens Next?

The Stock Island wastewater issue will need further testing and oversight to determine the best path forward. One potential solution is transitioning from shallow injection wells to deeper underground disposal systems, as the City of Marathon is currently doing, with its new well expected to be completed by the end of 2028.

As the situation develops, continued research, water quality monitoring and cooperation between local communities and regulatory agencies will be essential to protecting the marine ecosystems of the Florida Keys.

References

1. Florida Phoenix. (2026, July 30). Sweet samples shows sour truth: Sewage injected beneath Florida Key is bubbling back up. https://floridaphoenix.com/2026/07/30/sweet-samples-shows-sour-truth-sewage-injected-beneath-florida-key-is-bubbling-back-up/

2. Keys Weekly. Sanctuary advisory council resolution asks for answers on Stock Island wastewater discharges.https://keysweekly.com/42/sanctuary-advisory-council-resolution-asks-for-answers-on-stock-island-wastewater-discharges/

3. Friends of the Lower Keys (FOLKS). Organization website. https://www.friendsofthelowerkeys.org/

4. Keys Last Stand. Organization website. https://www.keyslaststand.org/

5. Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary. Advisory Council Meetings and Announcements.https://floridakeys.noaa.gov/sac/meetings.html

6. City of Key West. (2026, November 5). City Commission Meeting. https://keywest.legistar.com/MeetingDetail.aspx?GUID=A891799C-22E1-447C-BAC3-7A72E0B9DED5&ID=1459980

7. City of Marathon. Deep injection well facilities and wastewater infrastructure. https://www.ci.marathon.fl.us/

8. NOAA Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary. Water Quality. https://floridakeys.noaa.gov/ocean/waterquality.html

9. NOAA Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary. Threats to the Sanctuary.https://floridakeys.noaa.gov/science/research-and-monitoring/threats.html

10. U.S. Geological Survey. Fate and pathways of injection-well effluent in the Florida Keys.https://pubs.usgs.gov/publication/ofr94276